Kimberly Williams-Paisley as Gretchen Martin | Then
Speaking to Alan’s complicated relationship with his mother and his lack of confidence when dealing with women, he once again resorts to lying about his personal affairs in an attempt to make up for his own low sense of self-worth. This time it is in an effort to court character Larry Martin’s sister, Gretchen. Claiming that his son’s apartment is his, threading a web of lies regarding living with Charlie, his conscience once again catches up with him. This time the confession doesn’t sit well with his potential paramour and Gretchen breaks up with him.

Kimberly Williams Paisley As Gretchen Martin Then
